fredag den 4. maj 2018

Landmark Essays on Rhetorical Genre Studies

Two of my scholarly heroes, Amy Devitt and Carolyn Miller have joined forces and edited a volume of core texts from the dominant movement in genre research called Rhetorical Genre Studies; with a few small excursions to other, but strongly related, approaches to genre.

The book, Landmark Essays on Rhetorical Genre Studies has been given the following presentation on the publisher's homepage:


Landmark Essays on Rhetorical Genre Studies gathers major works that have contributed to the recent rhetorical reconceptualization of genre. A lively and complex field developed over the past 30 years, rhetorical genre studies is central to many current research and teaching agendas. This collection, which is organized both thematically and chronologically, explores genre research across a range of disciplinary interests, but with a specific focus on rhetoric and composition. With introductions by the co-editors to frame and extend each section, this volume helps readers understand and contextualize both the foundations of the field and the central themes and insights that have emerged. It will be of particular interest to students and scholars working on topics related to composition, rhetoric, professional and technical writing, and applied linguistics.

The choice of texts is also present on the homepage. Here is the table of content as rendered on the publisher's homepage:

Acknowledgements
Introduction
 Section 1 Foundations
Aristotle, On Genre (On Rhetoric: A Theory of Civic Discourse, Book I, Ch. 3)
Karlyn Kohrs Campbell and Kathleen Hall Jamieson, "Form and Genre in Rhetorical Criticism: An Introduction" (1978)
Carolyn R. Miller, "Genre as Social Action" (1984)
M. M. Bakhtin, "The Problem of Speech Genres" (1986)
John M. Swales, "A Working Definition of Genre" (1990)
Amy J. Devitt, "Generalizing about Genre: New Conceptions of an Old Concept" (1993)
Section 2 Systems and Interactions
Kathleen Hall Jamieson, "Antecedent Genre as Rhetorical Constraint" (1975)
Charles Bazerman, "Systems of Genres and the Enactment of Social Intentions" (1994)
Anne Freadman, "Uptake" (2002)
Section 3 Culture, Ideology, Critique
Catherine F. Schryer, "Genre Time/Space: Chronotopic Strategies in the Experimental Article" (1999)
Anis S. Bawarshi, "The Genre Function" (2000)
Anthony Paré, "Genre and Identity: Individuals, Institutions, and Ideology" (2002)
Section 4 Teaching
Aviva Freedman, "Show and Tell? The Role of Explicit Teaching in the Learning of New Genres" (1993)
Sunny Hyon, "Genre in Three Traditions: Implications for ESL" (1996)
Elizabeth Wardle, "’Mutt Genres’ and the Goal of FYC: Can We Help Students Write the Genres of the University?" (2009)
Index

The ambition  expressed in the description is completely to the point, and the selection of texts is a full roster of neo-classics—except, of course, Aristotle whose is merely a classic without any "neo" added. 

The only text here I don´t know beforehand is the very last one, but looking it up I find that it has a full  256 citations on Google Scholar which is fairly impressive, so I shall make myself acquainted with it at once. 

I notice in passing that the anthology has a four-item overlap with my list of RGS-studies for literary PhD students (Bakhtin, Miller, Freadman, Paré), and that no author present on my list is absent from Miller & Devitt's anthology. Obviously, I like the book for that. Personally, I would have switched Devitt's text for her 1991 article on the genre use of tax accountants because it corresponds so well with the 1994 text by Bazerman. But that's probably a personal preference, and the choice here is perfectly viable. Anyway, to each her own.

I don´t need to read the book to know that the choice of texts, the weight of the editors, and the scope of the volume makes this a well-nigh ideal reader of classic core texts in genre research. That it leaves off at 2009 is perfectly understandable. 

Of course, if you want to be completely up to speed in genre research you have to add later texts. But this is not the ambition of the present volume. And even if that had been the ambition it would be well-nigh impossible to pick the core text with so little distance in time and you would get an overlap with several of the important volumes of genre research that have been published since 2009. So, the cut-off is prudent.

In conclusion: if you want to know about genre research this is the book to buy. Incidentally, every text is itself a pleasure to read, so Landmark Essays on Rhetorical Genre Studies won´t even scare the academic bejesus out of you, just make you very much smarter very fast. Do not handle with caution. Dive in. Enjoy!

(Hey, reading this hagiography you'd think somebody paid me to write this. If only they would. But nobody paid me anything. The book is just going to be that good.)

Ingen kommentarer:

Send en kommentar